If Nietzsche Were a Narwhal | Justin Gregg

Summary of: If Nietzsche Were a Narwhal: What Animal Intelligence Reveals About Human Stupidity
By: Justin Gregg


Embark on a fascinating exploration into the depths of human intelligence and the potential ugliness that accompanies it in the book summary of ‘If Nietzsche Were a Narwhal: What Animal Intelligence Reveals About Human Stupidity’ by Justin Gregg. In this riveting study, discover the unique cognitive abilities and existential questions that differentiate human beings from other animals, as well as the inadvertent consequences resulting from this intellectual prowess. From philosophical theories to historical examples, this summary delves into the dangers of our innate creativity and resourcefulness, along with the self-destructive and socially harmful uses that have arisen through time. Get ready to challenge your understanding of human intelligence, and question whether our distinctive intellect indeed serves us well or not.

The Downside of Being a “Why” Specialist

Humans’ ability to ask probing questions and contemplate their own mortality has led to great achievements but also profound self-destructiveness, from mental illness to genocide.

Asking questions is a fundamental part of human thinking. However, our existential queries and tendency to contemplate our own mortality can have devastating consequences. Friedrich Nietzsche, a philosopher who envied the simplicity of cows, eventually succumbed to the weight of his own probing questions and ended up catatonic in a Swiss asylum. His sister later perverted his work to support anti-Semitic justifications for genocide.

This pattern of great ideas leading to terrible outcomes is not unique to Nietzsche or even humans. However, it is a tendency that only humans have regularly exhibited, using religion, philosophy, or even pseudoscience to support genocidal agendas.

While there is no doubt that our ability to ask probing questions and ponder life’s big mysteries has led to significant advancements in science and the arts, it has also increased our capacity for profound self-destructiveness. Perhaps we should take a cue from animals like the narwhal and accept our limitations. After all, wouldn’t it be an advantage not to experience life-threatening existential crises?

The Evolution of Why Questions and Bullshitting

In “The Rise of Why” by Chris Kutarna, it is revealed that why questions are a relatively new human phenomenon that arose about 43,900 years ago. Prior to that, humans relied on learned associations to survive. However, asking why questions allowed us to imagine and create causal connections, leading to the rise of science, medicine, art, and philosophy. While this led to tremendous progress, it also resulted in our minds being filled with dead facts that serve no practical purpose. Additionally, our pursuit of scientific and technological advancements has both helped and hurt us as a species. We are also excellent at bullshitting, which has become an evolutionary advantageous skill.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed