Derailed | Tim Irwin

Summary of: Derailed: Five Lessons Learned from Catastrophic Failures of Leadership (NelsonFree)
By: Tim Irwin


In the book ‘Derailed,’ Tim Irwin delves deep into the fascinating world of failed leadership, and how even the most accomplished executives can fall from grace. By exploring the lives of six well-known leaders who derailed due to their character flaws, Irwin offers valuable insights into the pitfalls of arrogance, lack of self-awareness, and failure to adapt. This book summary will provide you with a compelling glimpse into the inner workings of these high-profile cases while unveiling critical lessons about character, humility, and the importance of self-development in leadership roles. Be prepared for an enlightening journey into the psychology of success and failure, as you discover how even the most seemingly invincible leaders can ultimately succumb to their darker qualities.

Derailment of Successful Leaders

Top executives often fail due to a “failure of character” rather than criminal behavior. Derailment occurs when a leader deviates from a company’s goals and core values, extracting a heavy financial and cultural toll. The consequences of derailment are severe – firms can suffer losses or lose their cultural identity. Understanding the reasons behind derailment sheds light on corporate morality and showcases how even successful people can be impacted by flaws in character.

Embrace Your Dark Side

To avoid self-destruction during crises, it is crucial to understand all aspects of your personality – even the ones you hide. The book highlights that leaders who stay out of trouble acknowledge their vulnerability. Your weaknesses can undo you, and your strengths can become weaknesses. In stressful and powerful situations, concealed personality traits emerge, revealing your true nature.

Lessons in Leadership Derailment

Six well-known leaders fell from grace, teaching us valuable lessons on how to avoid character derailment, set strong direction, lead diverse teams, and achieve results.

Leadership is not just about achieving results, but also about setting direction, gaining alignment among diverse constituencies, risking change, building high-performing teams, going the extra mile, and enduring an ungodly amount of stress. Unfortunately, even the most accomplished leaders can stumble, and sometimes spectacularly so, due to their character flaws and obliviousness to the warning signs of possible derailment.

In this book summary, we learn from six well-known leaders who fell from grace, teaching us valuable lessons on how to avoid character derailment and lead with integrity. The case studies are Robert Nardelli, Carly Fiorina, Durk Jager, Steven Heyer, Frank Raines, and Dick Fuld.

Robert Nardelli was a rising star at General Electric, but he was stunned when he learned he would never become its CEO. Nardelli was quickly hired as Home Depot’s CEO, but he centralised the firm and increased his control, making himself more important than Home Depot. When his arrogance caused his firing, staffers high-fived in the hallways. The lesson here is never to let your ego get in the way of your leadership.

Carly Fiorina, who became known for her problem-solving acumen when she ran Lucent during its spinoff from AT&T, oversaw mass layoffs at Hewlett-Packard and blamed others for bad numbers. After five and a half years of steadily dwindling market share, the board fired her. The lesson here is that you are responsible for your results, and blaming others is the surest way to undermine your leadership.

Durk Jager’s “outstanding strategist” reputation got him appointed as Procter & Gamble’s CEO. He initiated rapid restructuring and cultural change, ignoring P&G’s 150 years of history and seeking huge mergers while searching for rebels among his staffers, making few friends and little respect. Employees feared him, and after 17 months, the board ousted him. The lesson here is that you should value your company’s culture and your employees’ buy-in, as change cannot be orchestrated respectfully and incrementally all the time.

Steven Heyer’s case is a bit different. With an impressive résumé, Heyer arrived as Starwood Hotels’ new CEO and expanded the brand, forging lucrative relationships with BMW and Apple. Nevertheless, he lost touch with his people, and an anonymous letter accused him of sending suggestive and provocative emails to one female staffer and having an inappropriate physical encounter with another. Heyer resigned, leaving some $35 million in stock, bonuses, and possible severance. The lesson here is that arrogance can make a leader too proud to fight, and resignation might not always be the best solution.

Frank Raines, despite his working-class origins, became the CEO of Fannie Mae, and under his leadership, the stock rose, and he earned roughly $90 million while there. Fannie Mae’s reach expanded, granting loans to low-income borrowers who never before had a chance at homeownership, but a whistleblower accused the company and its executives of accounting irregularities. Raines refused responsibility, resigned with $19 million in severance, and later paid more than $24 million in fines, surrendering $15.6 million in Fannie Mae stock options. The lesson here is that ethics and accountability should be at the core of your leadership.

Finally, Dick Fuld was the longest-serving CEO of Lehman Brothers, and he converted 1993’s $102 million loss into 2007’s $4.2 billion profit. However, Lehman Brothers lost billions in 2008, and Fuld became the symbol of failure and arrogant, overleveraged Wall Street. Fuld never took responsibility for Lehman Brothers’ failure, which cost him more in pride than in fortune. The lesson here is that, as a leader, you should take responsibility for your mistakes and listen to your team’s feedback.

Ultimately, these six leaders’ stories remind us of the importance of being self-aware, avoiding character derailment, and leading with integrity. Even if you have made mistakes in your leadership journey, you can learn from them and grow as a leader who sets strong direction, leads diverse teams, and achieves results while setting an example of ethical and accountable leadership.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed