Eating the Big Fish | Adam Morgan

Summary of: Eating the Big Fish: How Challenger Brands Can Compete Against Brand Leaders
By: Adam Morgan


Dive into the fascinating world of challenger brands with this summary of Adam Morgan’s ‘Eating the Big Fish.’ Learn how these underdog companies can compete and even thrive against dominant market leaders. Discover the key hurdles that challenger brands face in today’s competitive business landscape and explore the unique mindset and strategies they must adopt to succeed. Uncover the eight credos that characterize successful challenger brands, including intelligent naivety, lighthouse identity, and the use of powerful symbols. Embrace the possibilities offered by blurred product categories and changing consumer behavior, as you explore examples of challenger brands that have risen to great heights.

Unleashing Challenger Brand Power

Behind every dominant brand leader, there are challenger brands vying for market share. These underdogs may not have the same advantages as their top-tier competitors, but they can still make a significant impact in the business world by adopting a unique approach, innovative strategies, and overcoming hurdles to establish a strong presence in their respective markets.

Why is it that certain businesses always seem to have the upper hand over their competitors? These are the brand leaders โ€“ well-established, with clear competitive advantages, naturally enjoying larger profit margins than those beneath them: the challenger brands. Take a 2007 study by the Profit Impact of Market Strategy (PIMS) that discovered European brand leaders reaped a 40% return on investment, while their immediate competitors only managed 26%.

On the other side of the Atlantic, the numbers were similar, with American leaders obtaining a 32% return in comparison to the 18% earned by the number two brand. These leaders can invest more and thereby generate even higher profits. But it isn’t all doom and gloom for challenger brands.

It’s true; leader-status is the ultimate prize, but there’s still pride in being the second, third, or even fourth best. Let’s look at the case of the American car rental company, Avis. Although their competitor Hertz was ruling the industry, Avis, through a remarkable advertising campaign, managed to leapfrog into second place.

This triumph shows that despite their setbacks, challenger brands can still achieve greatness. All they need is a shift in mindset and the willingness to adopt creative strategies. But first, understanding the obstacles standing in their path helps them develop a stronger foundation to support their climb to the top of the market. With determination, grit, and innovative thinking, challenger brands can turn the tides and assert their presence in the competitive business world.

Capturing Attention Amid Chaos

In today’s fast-paced world, people gravitate towards comfort, particularly when stressed. This preference makes it challenging for new brands to penetrate the market and capture people’s attention. With everyone constantly engaged in their mobile devices, scrolling through social media, texting, and multitasking, our attention spans continue to shrink. Adding to the challenge is the fact that people are overwhelmed and crave moments of silence and solitude to rejuvenate, making them less receptive to marketing messages. Furthermore, trust in marketing has dwindled over time, fueled in part by past deceptive practices. In this dynamic landscape, challenger brands must overcome multiple hurdles to capture consumer attention and build trust.

The constant digital engagement and multitasking in people’s lives have led to shorter attention spans. A study from the United Kingdom discovered that 36% of texting occurs while watching TV, reflecting the growing prevalence of information overload.

Captivating audience attention becomes more challenging when considering people’s hunger for downtime. Stealing a few moments for themselves during their busy days, consumers prefer silence, avoiding intrusive advertisements and other distractions. This natural inclination to seek tranquility presents yet another hurdle for marketers trying to reach potential customers without causing annoyance.

Compounding the issue, mistrust of marketing has escalated over the years. A US study found that consumer trust in brands fell from over 50% to around 25% between 1997 and 2006. Factors such as aggressive sales tactics and misleading promotions have left target audiences suspicious of marketing strategies. Consequently, new brands must work even harder to establish credibility and trustworthiness.

In sum, challenger brands face a complicated landscape where attention spans are shrinking, audiences desire peace and quiet to recharge, and skepticism towards marketing is rampant. Navigating these obstacles requires innovative and thoughtful approaches to capturing consumer attention and developing trust.

Ditching Categories, Embracing Change

Human beings have a tendency to categorize everything, but in the world of products and marketing, these categories are becoming less reliable. Technology has blurred the lines between categories, making it difficult for marketers to rely on traditional classifications. This shift has expanded competition for businesses, as their products now compete with a broader range of products and services. Embracing this change rather than adhering to outdated categories can be the key to success for challenger brands.

Categorizing is a deeply ingrained human habit, which sometimes serves us well. However, when it comes to products and marketing, clinging to old ideas of categorization can be detrimental. Categories are becoming increasingly fluid, with technology blurring the lines that once easily defined a product’s purpose. For marketers, this means that traditional product or service classifications are no longer a reliable guide for understanding their target audience.

Take Flickr, for instance. Is it a social networking site, an entertainment platform, a research tool, or all of these? Its users continually find different ways to use the service, making a single category insufficient to capture its essence. And consider the iPhone – is it just a phone or also a camera or a browsing device?

In this new reality, categories are evolving based on what consumers need them to be, making it unproductive for marketers to focus on rigid classifications. However, this shift also has significant implications for businesses. The competition is no longer restricted to a single category but instead spans multiple areas of commerce. A company selling iPhones must now compete not just with other smartphone retailers, but also with camera companies like Nikon or Canon.

To adapt to this new landscape, businesses must be receptive to change and embrace it. They should recognize that their products might defy traditional categorization, and use this to their advantage. By rising to the challenge and capitalizing on the blurry boundaries, businesses can become agile, innovative, and more competitive in the market.

Unleashing the Challenger Mindset

Challenger brands, despite their diversity, share eight common traits known as credos. Of these, intelligent naivety stands out as a key characteristic, allowing individuals with limited experience to ask vital questions and develop unconventional, successful brands. By questioning the norms and utilizing their unique backgrounds, these brands can challenge established conventions and rapidly grow within their respective industries.

Challenger brands exhibit a unique set of shared features, known as “the eight credos,” that shape their behavior and drive their success. One particularly noteworthy credo is intelligent naivety, which empowers individuals with limited experience to transform their fields by asking important and unconventional questions.

Interestingly, extensive experience is not always an asset. For those who have spent years in a particular industry, it becomes difficult to see beyond the established norms and practices. The weight of experience may be blinding, preventing individuals from challenging conventions and exploring new approaches to their businesses.

On the other hand, possessing little or no knowledge of a field often fosters the curiosity needed to revolutionize any area. For example, Eric Ryan, the creator of Method โ€“ a line of home cleaning products โ€“ had no background in the cleaning solution industry. Instead, he came from a design-centered background, which led him to question the aesthetics of traditional cleaning bottles.

By watching popular home makeover shows, Ryan realized that cleaning products could be influential in creating a sophisticated atmosphere within a home. Collaborating with a friend, he developed an eco-friendly, well-designed cleaning solution that became an integral part of modern home design.

Due to Ryan’s lack of experience in the cleaning product industry and his unique perspective, Method quickly became the seventh-fastest growing packaged goods brand in the United States. This true story exemplifies the power of intelligent naivety, which leads individuals to break norms, leverage their unique experiences, and create successful challenger brands.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed