Identity Economics | George A. Akerlof

Summary of: Identity Economics: How Our Identities Shape Our Work, Wages, and Well-Being
By: George A. Akerlof


Ready to plunge into the world of ‘identity economics’? This book summary presents a thought-provoking account of the fusion between economics, identity, and social behavior, going beyond traditional economic studies. The core arguments formulate around career choices, gender discrimination, education systems, and workplace models, highlighting how identity markers such as race, class, and gender influence people’s personal choices. In the following summary, you will come across real-life examples drawing from various contexts, professions, and industries, revealing the importance of shared community values, group behavior, and social norms.

Understanding Identity Economics

Traditional economic studies focus on salaries and consumption patterns, whereas identity-based models add social factors like race and gender to understand personal and professional decisions. “Identity Economics” examines the interplay between economics, identity, and social behavior. It takes into account cognitive bias, psychological findings, and the impact of social context on real-life situations. The book looks at the career of Ann Hopkins, who sued her accounting firm for sex discrimination after being denied promotion due to her “abrasive” management style. The US Supreme Court ruled in her favor, highlighting how unstated rules and expectations impact crucial economic, educational, and employment decisions. This book makes a compelling case for incorporating identity-based economics into traditional economic models.

The Power of Social Factors

Personal choices are influenced by social factors such as race, gender, and class, which shape our identity and values. These factors are often overlooked by traditional economic theories that attribute decisions solely to individual preference. Advertisements, corporate actions, political parties, and community norms also influence our choices. Our identification with certain communities can change throughout our lives, and even children seek out peers of similar ages. External conditions, such as pollution, can also incite reactions from individuals and communities. Overall, understanding the impact of social factors on decision-making is crucial for businesses and policymakers alike.

The Influence of Identity on Smoking Habits

The book challenges traditional economic theories that solely focus on the demand for tobacco by introducing the concept of identity economics. It looks at how the tobacco industry, through clever marketing, was able to manipulate personal choices by linking cigarettes to liberation and equality.

Through a timeline, the book points out how societal attitudes towards smoking have changed for women over the years. The feminist movement opened doors to taboos against female smokers, leading to advertisements that made it desirable for women to smoke. The book also highlights that while traditional economics attribute the change in smoking patterns to the shrinking wage gap, it overlooks the impact of altered gender identities and social norms.

The discipline of economics has expanded beyond questions about income and consumption. The book examines how identity economics challenges traditional supply-and-demand theories by considering how social context, such as racism and discrimination, affects the financial decisions of real people in real situations. Studies have shown that African Americans are treated differently from whites by employers, bankers, and car dealers, which is indicative of the impact of identity on economic choices.

Identity and the Military

The military’s extreme makeovers and rituals during orientation are not explained by traditional economics. Instead, identity economics sheds light on how these actions create a sense of community and a new self-image. By enforcing a behavior code and discipline, the military changes recruits into insiders, enhancing their sense of community. Membership or “military identity” is valued over financial reward. This philosophy is reflected in the military’s pay structures, which have only a narrow difference between upper officers and lower-ranking personnel. Individual achievement is recognized not with money but with medals. Successful nonmilitary schools have also adopted this approach by creating an internal culture and developing “insider identities” to create a student community. The lesson here is that shared identity and a sense of community can drive better results than just monetary incentives.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed