Scarcity | Sendhil Mullainathan

Summary of: Scarcity: Why Having Too Little Means So Much
By: Sendhil Mullainathan


Imagine a world where time seems to run out, the pressures of daily life weigh heavily, and even a good day can feel consumed by scarcity. Welcome to ‘Scarcity: Why Having Too Little Means So Much’ by Sendhil Mullainathan, a book that exposes the profound impact of scarcity on our lives, whether it’s the shortage of time, money, food, or even emotional connection. In this summary, we’ll investigate the psychology of scarcity, unravel the connection between seemingly unrelated problems, and reveal the mechanisms of tunneling, bandwidth taxation, and scarcity traps that ensnare us. Explore how scarcity affects your day-to-day life and discover strategies to manage your resources, protect your bandwidth, and integrate slack in your schedule to achieve balance and success.

Scarcity’s Impact on Poverty and Diets

Scarcity, the feeling of having less than what you need, is the common link between seemingly unrelated issues like global poverty and diet struggles. Whether it’s time, money, food, or education, scarcity impacts our daily lives. We can often control our experience of scarcity through something called a critical safety valve. However, not having the freedom to manipulate our situations, like in poverty, represents an extreme form of scarcity. Regardless, the experience of scarcity is the same, affecting individuals in various aspects of their lives.

The Power of Scarcity

Scarcity causes obsession over what we lack, changes our interpretation of information, and alters our experiences of the world.

Food is a basic need that becomes overwhelming when scarce, and it’s not the only thing that can consume us when we experience scarcity. This is demonstrated by the University of Minnesota’s experiment with 36 male subjects who were starved and then fed in different ways to solve the problem of bringing back concentration camp inmates from the edge of starvation. The experiment reveals that scarcity not only causes a physical weakening of the body but also an obsession with what is lacking. The subjects became caught up with food, comparing prices, fantasizing about new careers and starting restaurants, and focusing only on food scenes in films.

Scarcity also alters how we interpret information. The processing of massive information in traumatic events like robberies or car accidents leads to a subjective expansion of time. Scarcity can have a similar effect on how we experience the world in that lonely people, whose lives center around observing others, are better at judging others’ moods and emotions than non-lonely people.

Understanding the power of scarcity helps us to recognize how its effects play out in our daily lives. We become obsessed with what we lack, our interpretation of information changes, and our experiences of the world alter.

The Power of Scarcity

The authors explain how scarcity affects our attention and productivity and present the concept of the tunnelling tax.

When presented with a coupon with no expiration date, most of us tend to put it off and never use it. The reason why lies in a phenomenon called tunneling, which refers to our ability to prioritize and efficiently manage pressing needs. Scarcity of time or resources makes us more attentive and focused on the task at hand, leading to positive outcomes, as the authors call it, the focus dividend. However, this intense focus on one thing comes at the expense of others and is described as the tunnelling tax. The authors give examples of the tunnelling tax, such as when we become so engrossed in a TV program that we ignore our friends or, in extreme cases, when firefighters are so focused on reaching a fire that they neglect safety considerations like wearing seat belts.

The authors also highlight the positive effects of scarcity and focus, such as the productivity benefits of having deadlines. A study showed that students given essays to proofread with differing deadlines were more productive when assigned one essay per week over three weeks than those given three weeks to proofread three essays.

In conclusion, the authors describe how scarcity affects our attention and productivity, and how the tunnelling tax results in a laser focus on one thing at the expense of others. The power of scarcity and focused attention can be both beneficial and detrimental, depending on the situation.

The Negative Impact of Scarcity on Our Bandwidth

Scarcity negatively impacts our bandwidth, which affects our ability to concentrate, make good decisions, and stick to our plans. This is demonstrated through a father preoccupied with work during his daughter’s softball match and a student who can’t focus on their exam due to financial stress. Top-down attention cannot prevent bottom-up intrusions like scarcity, which is involuntary and powerful. In a study of attention, dieters were less likely to see a red dot if they had just seen a picture of food, demonstrating attentional summary parting.

Escaping the Scarcity Trap

Scarcity can create a trap that keeps us behind, constantly juggling tasks. The solution is to give ourselves slack, or a cushion of space. This can prevent missed deadlines and spiraling out of control. While some situations don’t allow for the creation of slack, it’s vital for those who can.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed