The Motive | Patrick Lencioni

Summary of: The Motive: Why So Many Leaders Abdicate Their Most Important Responsibilities
By: Patrick Lencioni


Dive into the world of ‘The Motive’ to explore the journey of Shay Davis, a CEO struggling to generate growth at his home-security firm, Golden Gate Security. Amidst mounting pressure, he turns to business consultancy Lighthouse Partners to learn the secrets of effective leadership, only to be thrown into a surprising, insightful exchange with a rival CEO, Liam Alcott. As the two delve into the responsibilities and obligations of a CEO, they uncover and address the reasons behind leadership failures, ultimately transforming their outlook on what it means to be a true servant leader.

The Power of Collaboration

Shay Davis, the CEO of Golden Gate Security, sought expert business advice from Lighthouse Partners due to his company’s slow progress. When he discovered that one of Lighthouse Partners’ clients was his rival CEO Liam Alcott of Del Mar Alarm, he was initially reluctant to work with him. Nevertheless, Alcott convinced him to meet and discuss CEO leadership lessons that could help them both slow the influence of their mutual competitor. During their meeting, Alcott shared details of his financial fundamentals, which made Davis realize that his own company was not as productive as it could be. Alcott pointed out that Golden Gate’s salespeople were bringing in less revenue than Del Mar’s staff, and that Davis’s customer and employee turnover rates and marketing costs were much too high. Although Davis felt ashamed of his company’s poor performance, he asked Alcott to be candid and help identify any methods undermining his company. This successful collaboration helped transform Davis’s company, and he learned the valuable lesson that sometimes the best way to overcome competition is by working together.

A Tale of Two CEOs

Two CEOs with vastly different ideas about the role and responsibilities of a CEO come to unexpected conclusions in a thought-provoking conversation.

In “A Tale of Two CEOs,” two executives, Davis and Alcott, have a conversation about the role and duties of a CEO. Alcott, who had been mentored by a successful CEO, emphasizes the importance of focusing on managing and leading. He believes that these are the only activities a CEO should focus on, leaving everything else to the management team unless assistance is required.

Davis, on the other hand, values sales, marketing, and mergers and acquisitions, paying close attention to the company’s numbers. He considers management and dealing with employee issues as less important and enjoyable.

During their conversation, Alcott and Davis discuss the significance of meetings. Alcott believes in the importance of meetings but warns about the dangers of bad ones. Davis admits to wanting to avoid meetings entirely, considering it one of the perks of being a CEO. Alcott emphasizes the need for a CEO to be hands-on in assisting executives to improve. Davis, however, believes his experienced executives do not require such assistance.

As their conversation continues, Davis becomes aware that he is unsuited for the CEO role and that he had seen it as a prize, not a responsibility. He decides to leave his position as CEO and instead works for Alcott in marketing and M&A, a role that suits him perfectly.

The conversation between these two CEOs highlights the vastly different ideas and approaches towards the CEO role, making for an interesting and thought-provoking read.

Leaders as Gift Givers

The book argues that many leaders waste opportunities to lead organizations effectively because they see their positions as rewards for personal interests instead of gifts. The author cites Alan Mulally, former CEO of Ford, as a model executive who views leadership as a gift. The book emphasizes that leaders must be motivated by a deep sense of purpose and commitment to the greater good, not just personal ambitions or preferences. Leaders who prioritize their own interests over those of the organization and its stakeholders risk squandering their potential and failing to achieve long-term success.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed