Who | Geoff Smart

Summary of: Who: The A Method for Hiring
By: Geoff Smart


Hiring can be an overwhelming task, especially when it comes to finding that perfect fit for your organization. With ‘Who: The A Method for Hiring’ by Geoff Smart, you can anticipate a comprehensive and detailed hiring guide that covers crucial areas like defining your hiring needs, assessing cultural fit, utilizing networking for hiring, conducting effective interviews, and ensuring your employees feel motivated and included. This essential guide helps you through every step of the hiring process, in order to save your company the high cost of hiring the wrong person while securing the best possible match for the role.

Hiring Mistakes

Hiring the wrong employees can be a costly mistake for any organization and happens more often than it should. The article explains the impacts of bad hiring decisions and why relying solely on gut instinct or tricking candidates during interviews is risky. Making sound hiring choices requires expertise and a better approach that is explored in the article.

Hiring the right employees can transform an organization to success, but the significance of hiring the wrong person should not be underestimated. Bad hiring decisions cost companies a fortune and are more frequent than they should be. According to the studies done by the authors, a typical hiring mistake costs an organization around fifteen times the employee’s monthly salary.

Gut instinct as a basis of hiring decisions is commonly used by managers, but it is not always reliable. Gut feelings can deceive the recruiter, and first impressions can be weak guides. Moreover, most managers make at least 50% of their mistakes during hiring decisions, according to management guru Peter Drucker. Recruiting techniques like trying to catch the candidate off-guard during interviews can prevent the manager from discovering the prospect’s aptitude for the position.

Making sound hiring choices requires expertise. It is necessary to improve recruiting skills and policies to avoid bad hiring decisions. The article explores better approaches to make sound decisions. Consequently, it is essential to attract candidates who share similar values with the enterprise and improve competency-based assessment techniques to make informed decisions.

In conclusion, bad hiring decisions are expensive for organizations. Sound recruiting policies are necessary to avoid hiring errors that can cost an organization a fortune. The article explains the challenges of hiring decisions and the significance of sound recruiting skills and policies.

Defining Hiring Needs

To ensure a successful hiring process, it’s crucial to define your hiring needs right from the start. Hiring without knowing precisely what qualifications you need can result in hiring the wrong candidate. Recruiters often forget to define exactly what they’re looking for, which can derail the entire process. Defining hiring needs avoids hiring a generalist and ensures someone with specialized skills is hired. One of the most common mistakes in hiring is hiring an all-round candidate. Defining your hiring needs is important to avoid costly mistakes that may harm business operations.

A Cultural Fit

Intellect and smarts alone do not make an employee great. Social skills and cultural fit are equally vital, as one-third of CEOs admit to having made massive hiring mistakes by overlooking the importance of a cultural fit, according to the authors of a new book. Defining your company culture from day one can prevent this mistake. Bring your leadership team together and ask them to describe your company environment with catchwords such as analytical, dynamic, fast, and informal. A cultural fit may require saying no to highly talented people who do not share your company’s values. The case of the NPO Institute for Sustainable Communities illustrates this point. Despite doing an excellent job in managing to transform the opinion of African countries regarding the AIDS crisis, the brilliant new hire, who was not a team player, had to be let go as his work-style negatively impacted the overall team’s performance. Therefore, it’s crucial to hire not only for skills but also for cultural fit, as company culture is more important.

The Golden Rule of Hiring

Companies should continuously look for potential hires and utilize their networks for referrals to find the best candidates.

Hiring is crucial to many billion-dollar companies, yet traditional methods of only searching for new employees when needed can lead to rushed and poor hiring decisions. Seeking out referrals from one’s own networks – both business and private – is the golden rule of hiring, according to 77% of CEOs interviewed by the authors. It’s essential to continuously search for potential candidates and not just when a vacancy is imminent. For example, the CEO of Aon Corporation allocates a significant amount of time to finding new talent for the company, with a goal of discovering 30 new potential hires every year. This way, the organization always has a substantial pool of exceptional candidates when a specific position opens up. Nonetheless, even with a pool of potential candidates, it’s critical to choose the right person for the job. The book’s following segment elaborates on the methods of making successful hires.

The Four-Interview System

In order to make sure that your hiring decisions are as precise as possible, the author suggests utilizing a four-interview system. This system is designed to gradually increase in precision as the hiring process advances. The first interview is the screening interview, which should be conducted by phone and only last for thirty minutes. During this interview, the interviewer should focus on the candidates’ professional goals, strengths, weaknesses, and former boss performance review. The goal of this interview is to eliminate candidates who are not a good fit for the job. The author stresses the importance of conducting the other three interviews in order to fully assess the candidate, which includes the who interview, focused interview, and reference interview. Through implementing this comprehensive interview approach, the likelihood of finding the perfect match for the role is greatly increased.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed