Too Big To Know | David Weinberger

Summary of: Too Big To Know
By: David Weinberger


Immerse yourself in the intriguing world of ‘Too Big To Know’ by David Weinberger, a thought-provoking exploration of the transformation of knowledge in the digital age. In the age of the internet and limitless information, traditional methods of knowledge generation and dissemination are evolving rapidly. The book delves into the shift from relying on ‘expertise’ to embracing ‘networked’ knowledge powered by diverse online crowds. Understand how institutions like universities, libraries, and science labs must adapt as the infrastructure of knowledge undergoes a remarkable change. Unravel insights about the new shape and nature of knowledge driven by connected networks forming a ‘smart room’ and the challenges and opportunities it brings to mankind.

The Transformation of Knowledge in the Digital Age

In the past, knowledge was built upon a foundation of established expertise, but the introduction of digital media has revolutionized this system. Today, online information is abundant, making it challenging to distinguish truth from falsehood. As a result, institutions must rethink how they conceptualize knowledge’s infrastructure in light of the changing landscape. While some fear that the internet is making us stupid or giving a platform to every nut, others see an unprecedented opportunity for previously unlikely thinkers to tackle and solve problems. The digital age is reshaping the nature of knowledge into something new and networked, where the smartest person in the room is the room itself. In this context, knowledge is inextricably linked to the network that supports it.

The Flawed Filters of Digital Media

Organizational theorist, Russell Ackoff, explained the pyramid that captures how information is filtered and presented over the years. However, the rise of digital media has made traditional filtering techniques obsolete. With algorithmic and social tools, the filters no longer filter out but filter forward, bringing their results to the front. The web offers limitless content, including lots of idiotic or wrong material. Traditional methods must change to adapt to the new digital age.

The Evolution of Expertise

Despite changes in the way knowledge is acquired, people still rely on experts for opinions and education. However, traditional expertise is being challenged by collaborative networks that allow for the development of ideas by groups instead of individuals. The value of traditional expertise lay in the certainty of its conclusions, with authors focusing on a single subject, speaking in a consistent voice and speaking one way to the public. The rise in collaborative networks challenges the hierarchical nature of traditional expertise, presenting both opportunities and threats.

Networked Know-How

The Internet allows for networked expertise through virtual crowdsourcing, where diverse individuals come together to tackle problems and generate real-time knowledge. While crowdsourcing is not a new concept, the internet’s vast reach allows for a greater degree of expertise to be harnessed and enables subnetworks of like-minded individuals to combine their knowledge. The internet functions as a hub medium that scales indefinitely to facilitate interactions. However, diversity of thought and perspective is essential to the success of crowdsourcing, and proper moderation is crucial to staying on task and maintaining effective communication. The Internet’s ability to retain every post or entry generates a form of networked know-how that is constantly evolving.

The Pitfalls of Web Collectivism

In the digital age, web collectivism often leads to the creation of echo chambers, reinforcing existing beliefs and making people more narrow-minded. Conflicting opinions rarely penetrate these chambers, hindering the crucial exchange of ideas. While the internet has the potential to serve as a rational public forum, the abundance of voices makes it challenging to reach a consensus. Postmodernist ideas, like the interpretation of knowledge and experience as social, are becoming increasingly relevant in this context. All interpretations are influenced by cultural, linguistic, historical, and human factors and occur within discourses, within a context.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed