Madness in Civilization | Andrew Scull

Summary of: Madness in Civilization: A Cultural History of Insanity
By: Andrew Scull


Welcome to the journey through ‘Madness in Civilization: A Cultural History of Insanity’ by Andrew Scull. Explore the fluctuating definitions of ‘madness’, taking a deep dive into historical viewpoints and treatments of mental illness that span cultural and religious contexts. Learn about the Judeo-Christian tradition of regarding madness as a divine punishment, the scientific theories of Greeks and Romans, and the role of the Arabs in preserving and spreading medical knowledge. This summary aims to elucidate complex concepts while maintaining a user-friendly and captivating tone, perfect for readers eager to expand their understanding of the intricacies of societal views on mental illnesses throughout history.

The Perceptions of Madness Throughout History

The author explores how madness has been defined and viewed in different cultures and time periods. From the Judeo-Christian belief of it being a punishment from God to the Greek and Roman’s scientific approach of balancing the humors in the body to treat mental illness, the author provides insight on the various debates and theories around the causes of madness throughout history.

The Influence of Arabic Medicine

Arabic culture has played a significant role in the preservation and spread of medical knowledge throughout history. While the Arab conquests caused the loss of centuries-old Persian medical knowledge, they later sought out and studied Greek and Latin medical texts after the fall of Constantinople in 1453. The Arabs combined supernatural explanations with empirical reasoning for understanding mental distress, leading to the production of the most important medical text in history, The Canon. This text summarized all known medical knowledge and was translated into various languages and used as a textbook until the eighteenth century. Without the influence of Arabic intellectualism and learning, medical science today would be much poorer.

Enlightenment and the Reign of Superstitions

The Enlightenment era that took place between the 16th and 18th centuries in Europe had far-reaching consequences on people’s understanding of the world. Despite the philosophers of the time, such as Voltaire and Hume, promoting the values of rationality, the belief in superstitious entities still held firm in society. The book highlights the implications of this contradiction through the persecution of witches, who were often those with mental health issues. The witch-hunts claimed thousands of innocent lives as people who were mentally disabled or ill were accused of possessing supernatural powers. Even though artists and playwrights of the era demonstrated the link between madness and creativity, the consequences of this erroneous link were deadly. Consequently, religion and rationality’s intersection during the Enlightenment era is explored, laying bare the cost of superstitions in society.

The Historical Stigma of Mental Illness

For most of history, mental illness was misunderstood and those suffering from it were ostracized from society. Small communities were ill-equipped to deal with mental health issues, leading to sufferers being left without treatment, food, or shelter. Even worse, they faced corporal punishment and harmful procedures such as exorcism. The Catholic Church offered exorcisms as a remedy to mental illness, which rarely worked and sometimes resulted in harm or death. With no scientific method to review these practices, they continued for centuries, denying those with mental illness the help they needed. It’s only in recent times that mental illness has begun to be taken seriously and treatments have been developed.

The Dark History of Mental Health Treatment

Mental health treatment in the past was an appalling practice compared to today’s standards. The British Bethlehem hospital, also known as Bedlam, was a notorious example of the cruel treatment inflicted on patients. It was founded in 1247 and mainly admitted patients with physical ailments, and those with mental illness were primarily looked after from the seventeenth century onwards. Patients were mistreated, chained, and left to suffer in cruel conditions. Building dedicated madhouses to get those with mental illness off the streets was also common practice. These institutions were unregulated, and their owners charged exorbitant prices, making large fortunes from affluent families who wanted to confine their family members. The Marquis de Sade, for instance, was incarcerated for his sexual deviancy, which was damaging to the family’s reputation. This dark history illustrates that the care and concern for well-being were not always top priorities, making it essential to understand the progress and the changes that have happened over time.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed