Nonsense | Jamie Holmes

Summary of: Nonsense: The Power of Not Knowing
By: Jamie Holmes


Get ready to explore the intriguing power of ambiguity in our everyday lives, as Jamie Holmes takes us on a journey through the world of nonsense in his book ‘Nonsense: The Power of Not Knowing’. The summary delves into the ways humor, marketing, and psychology intersect with ambiguity and how it often goes unnoticed. You’ll discover how ambiguity can be cleverly used in advertising, how it can influence beliefs and decision-making, and how children differ from adults in their perception of ambiguity. From politics and cults to romantic relationships and language learning, we’ll examine the ways this phenomenon shapes our decisions and understanding of the world around us.

The Power of Subtle Ambiguity

In our daily lives, there is a lot of nonsense and ambiguity that often goes unnoticed. However, humor often hinges on these subtleties, which grab and amuse us. Marketers understand that this kind of ambiguity is effective in getting people’s attention in advertising. Sweden’s Absolut Vodka capitalized on this in the 1980s and 1990s by featuring hidden bottles in their ads. For example, the “Absolut Boston” ad appeared to show random Absolut Vodka cases floating in Boston Harbor, but on closer inspection, they formed the shape of a bottle. The playful ambiguity in advertising can be a powerful tool, as it draws people in and intrigues them. However, nonsense can also have the opposite effect, so marketers must be careful not to go too far.

The Power of Ambiguity

Ambiguity can be a powerful tool in influencing people’s beliefs and decisions. Studies have shown that unresolved ambiguity creates anxiety, influencing individuals to cling onto what they feel more certain about. Harvard psychologists Jerome Bruner and Leo Postman conducted an experiment in which they quickly flashed playing cards with mismatched colors and symbols, inducing subconscious anxiety among the subjects without them noticing. This unresolved ambiguity had an effect on their opinions, causing them to cling onto things they felt more certain about. The psychologist Arie Kruglanski found that stress can also affect decision-making, as people were more likely to change their opinion in the presence of a loud printer if they were not confident in their initial opinion. Understanding the power of ambiguity can be useful in influencing others, particularly in important meetings or discussions.

Ambiguity and Creativity

Our ability to explain ambiguity decreases with age. Although it unnerves adults, children can easily make imaginative sense of it. In some forms of modern art, irrationality and ambiguity are widely present, sometimes making it difficult for adults to process. A study conducted in 2009 by Travis Proulx found that the uncertainty in Franz Kafka’s “A Country Doctor” made the test subjects more alert and able to identify patterns in a series of letters better than others who hadn’t read the text. This suggests that ambiguity can spark creativity and imagination.

The Danger of Simplistic Thinking

After 9/11, people preferred simple explanations, but straightforward answers are not always the best. Studying people’s behavior when seeking quick solutions, it was found that they tend to favor dictatorial systems. Dissenting minority voices are silenced because an inability to evaluate new or different options hinders their decision-making in politics. This mentality can lead to extreme behavior like Dorothy Martin’s cult, where people desire simple explanations over ambiguity. In politics, it can result in the adoption of incorrect policies, such as in the case of the US-led Invasion of Iraq. Many people opposed the attack, claiming that Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction, but they were silenced by the post 9/11 fear. Overall, simplistic thinking can be dangerous as it suppresses diversity in thought, impede decision-making abilities, and spur extreme cults.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed