Shop Class as Soulcraft | Matthew B. Crawford

Summary of: Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry Into the Value of Work
By: Matthew B. Crawford


In the age of consumerism and rapidly advancing technology, the art and value of manual work are often overlooked or even shunned. ‘Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry Into the Value of Work’ by Matthew B. Crawford delves into the importance of hands-on labor and the consequences of our increasing dependence on pre-made and disposable products. Through an examination of the current job market, education system, and working conditions, the book highlights the need for individuals to reclaim their autonomy and pride through learning and engaging in manual tasks. Deconstructing the stigma surrounding skilled labor, this summary will offer insights into finding meaning and satisfaction in one’s work.

The Lost Art of Repair

The modern world is dominated by complex, delicate products that discourage repair and self-reliance. Instead of making or fixing things, we have become dependent on businesses. However, with a growing dissatisfaction in not understanding the items we use and a demand for self-reliance, interest in manual work is on the rise. Despite the economical and effortful arguments against DIY, people are beginning to repair and create things for themselves. The deteriorating economy is only adding to the trend.

The Changing Definition of Success

The traditional belief that a college degree leads to a stable, well-paying job is being challenged by the increasingly important criteria of career success. Economist Alan Blinder predicts that the divide between educated and less-educated individuals is shrinking while the gap between jobs that can be done remotely versus those that require face-to-face interaction is growing. This means that certain professions, like doctors or service providers, will remain stable even in the face of automation and globalization. However, the proliferation of remote work means that traditional white-collar jobs are becoming less secure, and globalization threatens to outsource even highly-skilled positions. This has led to a shift in the perception of “good” jobs, with some experts suggesting that skilled manual labor may be a more reliable path to career success. Overall, the idea that a college degree guarantees a stable career is becoming increasingly outdated, and job seekers must adapt to changing criteria for success.

The Evolution of Work

The concept of work has been evolving since the introduction of factories; the assembly line led to a marked division of labor that separated complex mental tasks from jobs. As a result, the blue-collar industry was degraded, and white-collar jobs also became routine. This evolution has led to a fundamental change in the state of work, pushing schools to prepare students for a life spent confined to a cubicle. Technological advancements have allowed semi-skilled technicians to conduct laboratory analyses, reducing knowledge requirements and subsequent pay.

The Devaluation of Manual Trades

Over the past two decades, manual trades have been gradually phased out of schools. Education systems now prioritize the development of theoretical knowledge workers, which ignores students’ true passions and talents. This approach leads to a lifetime of job insecurity, as theoretical jobs are no longer the guarantee they once were. As a result, high schools now prioritize awarding degrees and grades, which act as a social function rather than actually teaching. Schools are not engaging with learning and students are disengaged and unfulfilled. There is a need to recognize and value the importance of manual trades in preparing students for a fulfilling career.

Demands on Knowledge Workers

The author, a knowledge worker, faced extreme pressure to quickly read and summarize academic articles for their employer. This pressure, coupled with the isolating nature of cubicle work, led to exhaustion and a lack of loyalty to the job. Managers also contributed by using vague language to deflect responsibility, causing a divide between themselves and their team. The demanding workload and unpleasant working conditions faced by knowledge workers can be just as challenging as manual labor.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed