Equality and Efficiency REV | Arthur M. Okun

Summary of: Equality and Efficiency REV: The Big Tradeoff (A Brookings Classic)
By: Arthur M. Okun


Immerse yourself in the captivating world of ‘Equality and Efficiency REV: The Big Tradeoff (A Brookings Classic)’ by Arthur M. Okun. This thought-provoking book addresses the delicate balance between human rights and the market in American capitalist democracy. Okun emphasizes the significance of ensuring prosperity and justice while exploring five characteristics of U.S. rights. Discover the ideologies of libertarianism, pluralism, and humanism and their implications on the market. Also, delve into the complex factors that impact an individual’s financial success and the role of government in addressing problems, such as discrimination and income inequalities.

The Trade-Offs of American Rights

The existing economic and social disconnect in American “capitalist democracy” seems hypocritical. However, maintaining a balance between human rights and the market is necessary for prosperity and justice. American rights have five characteristics, and they all come at a social and financial cost, regardless of personal circumstances. These characteristics also illustrate a tradeoff between equality and efficiency, as the prohibition against buying and selling rights infringes on personal freedom. While Americans have basic human rights, institutions encourage competition for economic success while enforcing social conformity.

Three Philosophical Approaches to Freedom and Equality

The book discusses three philosophical approaches to freedom and equality in relation to the government, the market, and human motives. Libertarians believe in limiting the government’s power but allow for market regulations to prevent harm. Pluralists argue that the market is “imperialistic” and that human rights must be preserved by limiting market expansion. Humanists maintain that human motives and interests are the foundation of a viable society and promote fairness for all. However, restrictions on the market must strike a balance between preserving freedom and preventing inequality, as rulers have used economic controls to maintain power.

The Unfair Advantage of Money

Money can buy advantages such as paying for bail or hiring experienced lawyers. It also allows corporations to engage in antisocial behavior that harms workers. However, breaking up corporations or instituting high taxes on the rich will not solve this issue. Instead, specific aids and sanctions must target exact violations.

The Paradox of Self-Interest

The book explores the paradox of self-interest in American society, where the majority support the free market despite the inequities it creates. While “radicals” argue that the media, owned by the wealthy, feed false information to maintain this support, conservatives believe that an efficient market benefits the majority. The rising tide lifts all boats, and extreme poverty or wealth is viewed as flaws, not fundamental defects of the system. Despite ethical concerns, self-interest motivates individuals to work for the good of their communities. Attempts to force people to give up self-interest have resulted in more oppressive societies. The book defines efficiency as getting the most out of human effort, physical capital, and natural resources. Ultimately, people hope to reap the benefits of an efficient market and avoid government intervention that would force them to share their gains with others.

The Invisible Hand and Its Limitations

Adam Smith’s “invisible hand” theory explains that the self-interest of consumers and manufacturers results in an efficient market that meets society’s needs without regulation. However, the market can be distorted by anti-competitive practices and advertising, and it does not account for negative environmental effects or inequality. The government had to intervene during the Great Depression to save millions of people from unemployment caused by the market’s failures. Although the “invisible hand” is a useful concept, it has its limitations and cannot be relied upon completely.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed