Green Gone Wrong | Heather Rogers

Summary of: Green Gone Wrong: How Our Economy Is Undermining the Environmental Revolution
By: Heather Rogers


In ‘Green Gone Wrong: How Our Economy Is Undermining the Environmental Revolution’, Heather Rogers delves into the dark side of the environmental movement and unveils the hidden costs of green investments. By examining practices in organic farming, eco-luxury housing, the palm oil industry, and renewable energy, Rogers argues that market-driven solutions have frequently led to negative impacts on the environment and small-business owners. Additionally, this book sheds light on the importance of regulations and community-driven initiatives in creating a sustainable future.

Challenges for Small Organic Farmers

Small organic farmers struggle to make ends meet despite commanding higher prices. Off-farm income is often necessary to survive, and increasing urbanization drives them away from their land. The official USDA organic certification is criticized for its inefficiency in testing produce and providing support to small farmers who are chemical-free. Moreover, big organic reinforces the economic and regulatory system that favors powerful food processors and agribusiness elites. Under the USDA guidelines, small meat processors find it pricey to maintain facilities, and consolidation in the beef industry has left few alternatives for farmers. The success of organic food has made life harder for small local farmers, as distribution channels prioritize deals with large producers for cost-effectiveness. As organic goes mainstream, its methods increasingly resemble environmentally destructive commercial practices that are meant to be challenged.

The Organic Sugar Industry’s Environmental Impact

The Upper Parana Atlantic Forest once covered 100 million acres, but deforestation for farmland, particularly organic monocrop sugarcane, has left only 8% remains. Lax organic certifiers enable even more deforestation, as the USDA’s NOP rules don’t prevent the destruction of existing ecosystems. AZPA, Paraguay’s largest sugar producer, exemplifies the concerning practices of some organic producers; they use manure from factory-farmed chickens fed arsenic to plump them up. Though small farmers can earn fair compensation and certification, AZPA retains ownership of their certification, which prevents them from selling organic cane to anyone but AZPA. As farming families grow, they clear more land to support themselves. While markets cannot register the larger effects of consumers’ choices, groups of small farmers can make a positive impact by obtaining organic and Fair Trade certifications. While a Zero Deforestation law passed in 2004, enforcement remains unfunded.

The Evolution of Eco-Luxury

In the 90s, being eco-friendly meant living in an austere home, but now, eco-luxury is the new trend. Passivhaus design, incorporating airtight construction, ventilation systems, and triple-glazed windows, has replaced earthships. While it comes with a hefty price tag, it’s effective in energy conservation. Similarly, communities like Vauban and Freiburg in Germany utilize solar power and encourage a car-free lifestyle. The primary reasons for food scarcity are political and economic, not supply.

In the 1990s, the concept of being eco-friendly was about living in an austere home made of recycled materials. However, today, the idea of “eco-luxury” has taken over, where you can do your part to avert climate change by buying things that support environmentally conscious practices. The half-buried structures known as “earthships” have given way to “Passivhaus” designs that incorporate heat-exchanger ventilation systems, triple-glazed windows, and thickly insulated walls that work behind the scenes to conserve resources. Although retrofitting existing houses with these tenets can help homeowners save energy, the upfront cost of such homes can only be afforded by the wealthy.

Apart from luxury homes, communities like Vauban and Freiburg in Germany have adopted solar power and a car-free lifestyle to promote sustainability. However, food scarcity is not due to a lack of supply, but political and economic constraints. While these upscale homes and communities come with a high price, they still offer long-term benefits of low maintenance and utility bills. The evolution of eco-luxury has shown that being environmentally conscious does not mean sacrificing comfort and luxury.

The Dark Side of Palm Oil Plantations

The demand for palm oil has led to the destruction of Borneo’s rainforests, with indigenous communities being exploited and the law ignored. Despite global condemnation, international corporations and the International Finance Corporation continue to fund the palm oil industry’s illegal and unethical practices. The US indirectly supports the industry through subsidies and by mandating biodiesel blends. Agreements to pay developing countries to preserve their forests lack protections for indigenous peoples, highlighting the need to question the limits of market mechanisms as tools for environmental preservation.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed