The Only Woman in the Room | Eileen Pollack

Summary of: The Only Woman in the Room: Why Science Is Still a Boys’ Club
By: Eileen Pollack


In ‘The Only Woman in the Room: Why Science Is Still A Boys’ Club,’ author Eileen Pollack delves into her own experiences within the male-dominated world of science, investigating the sexism that pervades the field to this day. Growing up, Pollack faced several roadblocks on her journey to study and excel in the subjects she loved. Through a captivating narrative, this book showcases the struggles of women in science and seeks to explain the reasons behind this gender disparity. Offering insights into the continued lack of representation and prejudice that women face in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) fields, the book brings forward both historical and contemporary examples, while examining the value of supportive environments and the importance of confidence in fostering success.

Breaking Barriers in STEM

Eileen Pollack grew up in a working-class resort area and faced numerous barriers while pursuing her passion in science and math. Despite being told by her principal that girls were not capable of excelling in those subjects, Pollack persisted and found allies in her high school teachers. With their support, she went on to become valedictorian of her graduating class, aced her Advanced Placement courses, and got into Yale University. Her story highlights the prejudices and stereotypes that continue to hinder women’s progress in STEM fields, despite evidence that shows women are just as talented and committed as men.

Overcoming Gender Barriers in Science

Nancy Hopkins Pollack, a member of the fifth class to accept women at Yale, shares her journey of breaking gender barriers in science. Despite initial struggles, such as feeling intimidated and isolated in male-dominated classes, and lacking female role models, she persevered and discovered a talent for abstract physics concepts. She shares how boys are conditioned to tough out difficult courses in unpopular subjects and how the sexism she experienced was rarely obvious. Despite these challenges, Pollack graduated in three years with a degree in physics and more importantly, paved the way for future generations of women to follow in her footsteps.

From Physics to Writing

When a physics major takes a nonfiction writing class, her life takes an unexpected turn. In the seminar, she discovers her hidden talent for writing and starts to crave recognition as much as she does in physics.

In this book, a physics major named Pollack recounts her experience taking a nonfiction writing seminar. Initially, the only reason she takes the course is to receive a recommendation letter from her professor for her interest in writing. However, that soon changes as she discovers her hidden passion for writing. For the first time in her academic life, she discovers that writing is a medium where she can earn recognition and acknowledgement beyond the physics courses she had taken.

As the course progresses, her writing talent catches the eye of the seminar’s professor, Martin Goldman, who encourages her to “foster a dialogue between the two cultures”. It is through the continuous feedback and open dialogue in the class that Pollack learns to enhance her writing skills and uncover her potential as a writer.

By the end of the seminar, Pollack is enrolled in an advanced nonfiction writing class with the Pulitzer Prize winner, John Hersey. Pollack’s experience illustrates the value of trying new things, discovering hidden talents, and seeking acknowledgement beyond one’s comfort zone.

From Math to Writing: A Woman’s Journey

When the Yale Daily News asked her to write a feature on the lack of women majoring in math, Pollack found that only one woman graduated from a math major the year before, mostly due to preparation. Women had only studied algebra while men were already exposed to calculus. As a result, Yale formed a new Office on the Education of Women and appointed Connie Gersick as director to change the situation. Later, Yale held its first conference on women in science, sponsored by the National Science Foundation, organized by Pollack and Gersick.

Pollack then decided to pursue a physics Ph.D., but she struggled on the graduate admission exams. She visited the strong physics program at UC Berkeley but couldn’t knock on the professor’s door and realized she didn’t want to spend more years as the only woman in the room. Additionally, Pollack realized that the culture of science can drive away not only female researchers but also men who care about their families.

She struggled to combine science and writing careers and wondered whether to stay in science by working in industry or writing grant proposals and articles, or continue her education. Then she received advice from a professor, who recommended becoming a writer who understands physics rather than a physicist dabbling in writing. Pollack followed his advice, left science after her undergraduate program, earned her MFA from the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, and became a successful author and writing professor.

Want to read the full book summary?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed